Packers-Ravens Trade(revised)

Packers Give: FS Nick Collins 93 A pot
OLB Clay Matthews 86 A pot
WR Donald DRiver 89 B pot

Ravens Give: FS Ed Reed 97 A pot
OLB Terrell Suggs 90 A pot
WR Derrick Mason 86 B pot
and a 3rd round pick

REVISED

the only way i can even consider this is if I see some ages

FS Nick Collins Age 28
OLB Clay Matthews 25
WR Donald Driver 36

Ravens -
FS Ed Reed 33
OLB Terrell Suggs 29
WR Derrick Mason 37

not approving this deal. packers are getting 2 guy who will probably retire after this year

what? Ed Reed retires in like 3 or 4 years. hes an elite player still and will be equal to collins at least. you ever advance far in offline franchise? it works the same way.

this trade is 100% fair. He gets higher overall players (pretty significantly higher) and i get a little younger. how isn't this fair?

Packers Give:
FS Nick Collins 93 A pot 28
OLB Clay Matthews 86 A pot 25
WR Donald DRiver 89 B pot 36

Ravens Give:
FS Ed Reed 97 A pot 33
OLB Terrell Suggs 90 A pot 29
WR Derrick Mason 86 B pot 37

Here is how i see it:
Ed Reed is an elite FS right now and I could agree if Packers wants to trade Collins for him.
Terell Suggs is a downgrade from Clay matthews I feel.
Then Mason is also a downgrade from Driver i feel.

I Disagree with this trade. basically giving up Ed Reed for better players when he is about worth as much as Collins

Approved 2 old's for 2 middle ages

Get FeArSoMe wrote:Packers Give:
FS Nick Collins 93 A pot 28
OLB Clay Matthews 86 A pot 25
WR Donald DRiver 89 B pot 36

Ravens Give:
FS Ed Reed 97 A pot 33
OLB Terrell Suggs 90 A pot 29
WR Derrick Mason 86 B pot 37

Here is how i see it:
Ed Reed is an elite FS right now and I could agree if Packers wants to trade Collins for him.
Terell Suggs is a downgrade from Clay matthews I feel.
Then Mason is also a downgrade from Driver i feel.

I Disagree with this trade. basically giving up Ed Reed for better players when he is about worth as much as Collins

^I agree with this point as well and have to also decline your trade

Packers Give:
FS Nick Collins 93 A pot 27
OLB Clay Matthews 86 A pot 24
WR Donald DRiver 89 B pot 35

Ravens Give:
FS Ed Reed 97 A pot 31
OLB Terrell Suggs 90 A pot 27
WR Derrick Mason 86 B pot 36

is this good now with the 3rd pick? 3rd picks are 75 overall rookies most of the time.

busturdust wrote:Packers Give:
FS Nick Collins 93 A pot 27
OLB Clay Matthews 86 A pot 24
WR Donald DRiver 89 B pot 35

Ravens Give:
FS Ed Reed 97 A pot 31
OLB Terrell Suggs 90 A pot 27
WR Derrick Mason 86 B pot 36
and a 3rd round pick

REVISED

Here is how i see it:
Ed Reed is an elite FS right now and I could agree if Packers wants to trade Collins for him.
Suggs is a slight downgrade from Matthews, but not much of one.
Then Mason is also a downgrade from Driver since Mason retires after 1 year and Driver after 2.

I would say a 5th would make up for Matthews and Suggs difference,
then lets say next year when Mason is 37 he would be worth about a 5th I would say.

So with that said a 3rd instead of two 5ths seems fine to me.

I would Agree to this trade if I had any authority

approved pending meantome's vote

I approve

completed pending draft picks