Panthers - Bengals Trade #2

Panthers Send:

LG - Travelle Wharton - 29 Years Old - 83 Overall - B POT

LE - Charles Johnson - 24 Years Old - 79 Overall - B Pot

WR - David Clowney - 25 Years Old - 68 Overall - C Pot

Bengals Send:

LG - Nate Livings - 28 Years Old - 77 Overall - ?? Pot

DT - Domata Peko - 25 Years Old - 86 Overall - ?? Pot

Livings - B pot, Peko - A pot


accept

Accepted

For my vote you are going to have to drop the 5th round pick and add more from the Panthers. If you call Clowney and the fifth equal (which I don't, you can get some really good players in these drafts), and look at the rest of the players the OVRs pretty much even out, and Carolina gets younger plus they get the stud Peko. Wharton and Johnson don't progress even close to Peko.

what do you suggest we do to even the trade out then, badguy?

So what about if I drop the 5th round pick from the deal, he wanted Clowney because of the speed and Clowney progresses decently

I guess if you drop the 5th I would approve. That would be close enough for me anyways. At least then your are getting an extra player for one that is so good.

Ok updated

1/3 votes

dont think bengals are getting enough

i agree with gonzo but because there is solid reasoning behind the move i will give it the go

2/3